What happens when the asset that always bailed you out stops doing its job?
That question sits at the heart of a recent Inc. article in which I was interviewed: “An Acclaimed Sonoma Winery Faces a $17.5 Million Suit. The Crisis Goes Far Beyond Weak Wine Sales,” by Lucia Auerbach. The article reports on a lender’s lawsuit against a well-regarded Sonoma producer and places it within a broader wave of financial distress across Napa and Sonoma. This industry-wide picture is one I am discussing more and more often with winery owners, vineyard owners, and buyers, so it is worth expanding on here.
The Ground Shifts
For a long time, land in Napa and Sonoma was treated as an asset that only went up, and that appreciation covered for thin operating margins. Some wineries might barely break even year after year while the dirt underneath them nonetheless quietly built wealth.
Not anymore. Owners today are dealing with softer grape prices, slower direct-to-consumer sales, higher interest rates, and rising insurance and labor costs, all at once. Land is still scarce, but it can no longer carry a business that isn’t making money on its own.
It’s Not the Wine, It’s the Loan
Many wineries expanded or bought property during stronger years, and many of those deals were underwritten on low interest-rate debt and the assumption that sales would keep growing. When those loans come up for renewal at today’s rates, or when a lender takes a fresh look at loan-to-value after a weak year, owners can find themselves out of compliance with their loan covenants even if the brand itself is healthy.
Translation: a winery can make good wine, have loyal customers, and still be in default.
In my view, many of the closures and bankruptcies we are seeing have less to do with the quality of the wine or the management and more to do with capital structures that were built for a different market.
Read the Fine Print (Before Your Lender Does)
Owners are having more frank conversations about bringing in partners, selling off parcels, selling the brand separately from the real estate, or exiting altogether. Whichever path makes sense, the time to plan is before a lender sets the timeline for you.
Start with your loan documents. Know your maturity and renewal dates, your financial covenants (debt service coverage and loan-to-value tests are the usual suspects), your reporting obligations, and exactly what counts as an event of default. Many owners are surprised by how little it takes to trip a covenant.
Then talk to your lender, and do it as early as possible. Amendments and forbearance arrangements are generally far easier to negotiate before a default than after a loan has been accelerated.
Next, look at how the business is put together. Holding the brand, the operating company, and the real estate in separate entities can open up options, whether that means bringing in an investor at one level or selling one piece without selling everything. If you do bring in partners, get the governance right. Control, capital calls, distributions, and exit rights matter far more when a business is under stress than when things are going well.
Finally, don’t forget the ABC. In California, new owners, new investors, and changes in control can trigger Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control requirements, and those timelines need to be built into any deal from the start.
One Owner’s Problem, Another Buyer’s Opportunity
There is another side to this story. Buyers with cash and patience, whether larger wine companies, family offices, or private equity, will have more opportunities than they’ve had in many years. I expect the financial stress to accelerate winery sales, outside investment, and consolidation in Napa and Sonoma, although prime sites should still command premium prices.
For buyers, careful diligence matters as much as ever: title and existing liens, use permit limits on production and visitation, water, grape contracts, and the licenses the business depends on. A bargain price does not make up for a winery that can’t operate the way you planned.
The Latest Cycle
I came to Napa from the wine side of the business. Before law school, I was a sommelier and wine buyer at the “21” Club in Manhattan, and I have watched this industry ride out more than one cycle since. The wine certainly still matters. But in this market, so does a capital structure that can survive a bad year.
Quick Answers
Why are so many Napa and Sonoma wineries in financial trouble? Softer grape prices, slower direct-to-consumer sales, higher interest rates, and rising insurance and labor costs, layered on top of debt taken on when rates were low and sales were growing.
Can a winery be in default on its loan even if its wine is selling? Yes. Loan agreements often include financial covenants and loan-to-value tests. A weak year, a lower appraisal, or a renewal at a higher rate can put an owner out of compliance even when the brand itself is healthy.
What options does a struggling winery owner have? Common options include renegotiating with the lender, bringing in an equity partner, selling non-core parcels, selling the brand separately from the real estate, or selling the business outright. The right choice depends on the loan terms, the ownership structure, and the owner’s goals.
About the Author
Matt Eisenberg is a business and real estate attorney in Napa, California. His practice includes entity formation and governance, contract drafting and negotiation, California alcohol beverage law, and real estate transactions, with a focus on the wine industry. To discuss a winery, vineyard, or wine business matter, contact Matt at matt@matteisenberg.com.
This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.